Top 100 game list from Famitsu? - http://www.mmcafe.com/ Forums

Return to site

Original message (3011 Views )

Bata kun

2834th Post

Platinum Carpet V.I.P- Board Master

"Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Mon 6 Mar 09:50

This is probably the most botched up list I've seen. Ever.

Discuss!

Replies:

GekigangerV

1212th Post

Red Carpet Executive Member

"Re(1):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Mon 6 Mar 10:09

quote:
This is probably the most botched up list I've seen. Ever.

Discuss!

It makes me sad that Tactics is the lowest rated of all the Final Fantasy games.

Rid

7030th Post

Platinum Carpet V.I.P- Board Master

"Re(2):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Mon 6 Mar 10:13

What did you expected, it's Famitsu! of course the list will make no sense.

sabo10

1345th Post

Red Carpet Executive Member

"Re(2):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Mon 6 Mar 13:01

quote:
It makes me sad that Tactics is the lowest rated of all the Final Fantasy games.

It makes me sad that you replied to this thread. And I mean that not in an insulting or hateful way, but in more of a fatherly, loving, dissapointed way.

Iggy

7557th Post

Platinum Carpet V.I.P- Board Master

"Re(3):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Mon 6 Mar 17:41

I'm not sure if it makes me sad that no one reads my random news thread, even when the Professor himself is posting in them.

Probably not, actually.

Time Mage

2338th Post

Platinum Carpet V.I.P- Board Master

"Re(4):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Mon 6 Mar 20:24

quote:
I'm not sure if it makes me sad that no one reads my random news thread, even when the Professor himself is posting in them.

Probably not, actually.

No one replies to your thread. That's a big difference. Even if it's full of news of strange games I've never heard of, there are usually news that interest me.

And yes, the Famitsu list sucks. But it sucks because it doesn't fit exactly with my personal tastes.

Gojira

1941th Post

Gold Carpet V.I.P- Platinum Executive

"Re(5):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Mon 6 Mar 20:37

Looks more like a list of top 100 commercial successes.

Radish

3142th Post

Platinum Carpet V.I.P- Board Master

"Re(6):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Mon 6 Mar 20:57

quote:
Looks more like a list of top 100 commercial successes.

That makes sense since it's a reader generated poll so stupidly popular games will work their way to the top.

The best part is that the original Tokimeki Memorial is good enough to be on the list twice.

Moriya
51th Post

Occasional Customer

"Re(7):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Tue 7 Mar 01:31

I can understand the Japanese liking FFVII and even FFX better than FFVI.

But they also prefer FFIV, FFIII (!), FFV, FFVIII AND FFIX to FFVI??? Woah.

κατά τον δαίμονα εαυτού.

Gojira

1942th Post

Gold Carpet V.I.P- Platinum Executive

"Re(8):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Tue 7 Mar 04:52

quote:
I can understand the Japanese liking FFVII and even FFX better than FFVI.

But they also prefer FFIV, FFIII (!), FFV, FFVIII AND FFIX to FFVI??? Woah.

It's possible. I'd often heard people who played both when they were new say FFVI was a big step down from FFV in terms of gameplay.

Bata kun

2838th Post

Platinum Carpet V.I.P- Board Master

"Re(9):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Tue 7 Mar 05:23

quote:
I can understand the Japanese liking FFVII and even FFX better than FFVI.

But they also prefer FFIV, FFIII (!), FFV, FFVIII AND FFIX to FFVI??? Woah.

It's possible. I'd often heard people who played both when they were new say FFVI was a big step down from FFV in terms of gameplay.

Yeah. You have to remember. Characters in "VI" are assigned a job. You don't have the job flexibility there like you do in "V".

Shooo-rook
105th Post

Regular Customer

"GTA all alone" , posted Tue 7 Mar 10:03

quote:
This is probably the most botched up list I've seen. Ever.

Discuss!

Gta: Vice city... all alone with RPGS and fighters surrounding it

Are you slave to the blade?

Moriya
52th Post

Occasional Customer

"Re(10):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Tue 7 Mar 10:17

quote:
I can understand the Japanese liking FFVII and even FFX better than FFVI.

But they also prefer FFIV, FFIII (!), FFV, FFVIII AND FFIX to FFVI??? Woah.

It's possible. I'd often heard people who played both when they were new say FFVI was a big step down from FFV in terms of gameplay.

Yeah. You have to remember. Characters in "VI" are assigned a job. You don't have the job flexibility there like you do in "V".

Hmmm... still, that was a little shocking to me when I first saw the list. Everywhere outside Japan, FFVI seems to be amongst the more popular FFs. And it's definitely more popular than FFIII, FFIV and FFV, at least. That just came as a surprise to me.

κατά τον δαίμονα εαυτού.

gorgeous
98th Post

Occasional Customer

"Re(1):GTA all alone" , posted Tue 7 Mar 11:19

quote:
This is probably the most botched up list I've seen. Ever.

Discuss!

Gta: Vice city... all alone with RPGS and fighters surrounding it

GTA is DA BOMBだから

nobinobita
25th Post

Rare Customer

"Re(2):Re(10):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Tue 7 Mar 21:07

One thing to keep in mind is that just cos they're Japanese doesn't make them hardcore gamers. I guess this list is a good indication of what the casual gamer over there likes, just as EGM is indicative of what casual gamers here tend to enjoy.

I am suprised that FFVI is below all those other FFs though.

And it also makes me sad that Grandtheft Auto is popular enough to make the list there.

Professor

2288th Post

MMCafe Owner

"Re(5):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Tue 7 Mar 21:19:

quote:
I'm not sure if it makes me sad that no one reads my random news thread, even when the Professor himself is posting in them.

Probably not, actually.

No one replies to your thread. That's a big difference.

2258 Views kind of says that everyone is enjoying ROM'ing.
(Note: ROM = Read Only)

About the top 100s. Personally, I think there's a generation transition happening with the readers of Famitsu. I wonder how many of its readers have actually played Super Mario Brothers.

To put it another way, nobody that I know of reads Famitsu any more.

[this message was edited by Professor on Tue 7 Mar 21:27]

HARO
35th Post

Rare Customer

"Re(1):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Wed 8 Mar 02:17

Japan loves them some RPGS. I can't believe final fantasy 6 (3 in the US) is under some of the other FFs.

I stopped reading the list at Metal Gear Solid 3. What a joke.

gorgeous
101th Post

Regular Customer

"Re(6):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Wed 8 Mar 14:11

quote:
I wonder how many of its readers have actually played Super Mario Brothers.

Well, obviously enough had played Super Mario Bros. 3 to vote it #99!

. . . that's so, so . . . I don't know. It makes me feel weird.

And yeah, I think it says a whole lot that Final Fantasy VI is right below Final Fantasy IX. Hell!!

makatiel
182th Post

Regular Customer

"Re(7):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Wed 8 Mar 18:13

what is machi? i've never even heard of it.

is it any good?

Maese Spt
184th Post

Regular Customer

"Re(8):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Thu 9 Mar 02:08

Honestly, does anyone still give a damn about Famitsu and its "opinions"?

Maybe years ago it was the reference magazine on japanese videogames, but now has become the japanese version of Hobby Consolas. Spanish folks would know what I'm talking about, lol.

"At his coming

the gods themselves are put to flight and the Buddhas vanish"

CHAZumaru

367th Post

Silver Customer

"Re(8):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Thu 9 Mar 02:57

quote:
what is machi? i've never even heard of it.

is it any good?

SegaSaturn sound novel, by Chun Soft. Re-released on PSP by Sega this spring.

NOW IS TIME TO THE 68000 Z80 AND SH-2 HEART ON FIRE !!

Sensenic

1461th Post

Red Carpet Executive Member

"Re(9):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Thu 9 Mar 07:06

quote:
Honestly, does anyone still give a damn about Famitsu and its "opinions"?

Maybe years ago it was the reference magazine on japanese videogames, but now has become the japanese version of Hobby Consolas. Spanish folks would know what I'm talking about, lol.

You mean Famitsu is the best magazine out there in the market, with wise and critical reviews that are not biased in any way by factors such as favoritism or "other external ones", and an open attitude that tries to get to every kind of public, trying to help them form a criterium of their own?

Cool!

Spoiler (Highlight to view) -
Irony? Why, my blood iron level is good, thanks.

End of Spoiler

Deidara. I just loved that face. XD

"It's you know like when you die and you can't quite believe it"
An undead friend.

Evenor

323th Post

Bronze Customer

"Re(10):Famitsu: Persona 3!?!?!" , posted Thu 9 Mar 07:14

According to IC, Famitsu revealed that there is a Persona 3 for PS2 in the making ( with Shigeki Soejima designs).

Any scans!?!?!

肝臓入りのオレンジジュース!
腎臓混じりの甘口カレー!
膵臓仕込みのペスカトーレ!
愛しの愛しのサイコホラー

Iggy

7563th Post

Platinum Carpet V.I.P- Board Master

"Re(2):Re(10):Famitsu: Persona 3!?!?!" , posted Thu 9 Mar 07:34

quote:
Any scans!?!?!

Yes. Plenty.

Shooo-rook
106th Post

Regular Customer

"Re(10):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Thu 9 Mar 07:55

quote:
Honestly, does anyone still give a damn about Famitsu and its "opinions"?

Maybe years ago it was the reference magazine on japanese videogames, but now has become the japanese version of Hobby Consolas. Spanish folks would know what I'm talking about, lol.

You mean Famitsu is the best magazine out there in the market, with wise and critical reviews that are not biased in any way by factors such as favoritism or "other external ones", and an open attitude that tries to get to every kind of public, trying to help them form a criterium of their own?

Cool!

You have enough iron..y to donate blood

Are you slave to the blade?

Evenor

324th Post

Bronze Customer

"Re(3):Re(10):Famitsu: Persona 3!?!?!" , posted Thu 9 Mar 08:23

quote:
Yes. Plenty.

Is it pretty? Any returning characters?

肝臓入りのオレンジジュース!
腎臓混じりの甘口カレー!
膵臓仕込みのペスカトーレ!
愛しの愛しのサイコホラー

exodus

3301th Post

Platinum Carpet V.I.P- Board Master

"Re(6):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Thu 9 Mar 09:15

quote:

To put it another way, nobody that I know of reads Famitsu any more.

Still...500,000 people per week! Somebody is reading it. Mystery!

Pollyanna

1675th Post

Tailored Carpet V.I.P- Platinum Member

"Re(4):Re(10):Famitsu: Persona 3!?!?!" , posted Thu 9 Mar 10:21

quote:

Is it pretty? Any returning characters?

Igor. It's VERY VERY PRETTY. But quite different than the previous games. More colorful. I don't know what to think. It's not quite "Persona", but it looks fantastic.

Given the setting, returning characters are highly unlikely.

CHAZumaru

368th Post

Silver Customer

"Re(5):Re(10):Famitsu: Persona 3!?!?!" , posted Thu 9 Mar 11:37

Evenor, you can download a long promotion video here.

Though I don't care about Persona as much as about DeviSumo, Saejima's designs and the HUD are magnificent. On the other hand, I don't understand the choice of almost-SD characters.

NOW IS TIME TO THE 68000 Z80 AND SH-2 HEART ON FIRE !!

Evenor

325th Post

Bronze Customer

"Re(6):Re(10):Famitsu: Persona 3!?!?!" , posted Thu 9 Mar 12:53

quote:
Evenor, you can download a long promotion video here.

Thank you very much for the video.

This game looks gorgeous!!!
The only thing I dont like is that the actual in-game character models look very young. (They remind me of Radiata Stories characters)

Expected release date?

肝臓入りのオレンジジュース!
腎臓混じりの甘口カレー!
膵臓仕込みのペスカトーレ!
愛しの愛しのサイコホラー

Pollyanna

1676th Post

Tailored Carpet V.I.P- Platinum Member

"Re(7):Re(10):Famitsu: Persona 3!?!?!" , posted Thu 9 Mar 13:46

quote:

Expected release date?

July 17.

Ishmael

2416th Post

Platinum Carpet V.I.P- Board Master

"Re(7):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Thu 9 Mar 23:36

quote:

To put it another way, nobody that I know of reads Famitsu any more.

Still...500,000 people per week! Somebody is reading it. Mystery!

But doesn't GamePro -a magazine nobody would admit to owning- claim to have 3 million readers? I suspect Famitsu is counting the people who view illegally uploaded scans of their magazine as readers.

CHAZumaru

371th Post

Silver Customer

"Re(8):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Thu 9 Mar 23:49

quote:

To put it another way, nobody that I know of reads Famitsu any more.

Still...500,000 people per week! Somebody is reading it. Mystery!

Bu it used to be around 800,000 readers. So Prof's friends might be part of those 300,000 that disappeared in a few years.

NOW IS TIME TO THE 68000 Z80 AND SH-2 HEART ON FIRE !!

makondo99

325th Post

Bronze Customer

"Re(6):Re(10):Famitsu: Persona 3!?!?!" , posted Fri 10 Mar 03:13

quote:
video

It does look pretty! Unfortunately, I guess the chance of seeing and English release is below zero. To begin with, Persona games are quite obscure and

Spoiler (Highlight to view) -
in the video the characters are pointing guns to their heads

End of Spoiler

a thing that would indeed freak out concerned parents/be another scapegoat to media to blame suicides on videogames.

Professor

2292th Post

MMCafe Owner

"Re(9):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Fri 10 Mar 03:45:

quote:

To put it another way, nobody that I know of reads Famitsu any more.

Still...500,000 people per week! Somebody is reading it. Mystery!

Bu it used to be around 800,000 readers. So Prof's friends might be part of those 300,000 that disappeared in a few years.

One more thing to remember: Famitsu's figures are completely self-declared. The company doesn't release its so-called "real print figures", which requires an authentification with a certificate. (Insatsu-Shoumei)

Typically, only magazines that either aren't selling well, or might run into major issues by releasing its real figures do that. Like Shounen Champion. Without Grappler Baki, that magazine is as good as gone. Not that I'm comparing the two.

Famitsu is definitely #1 in videogame magazines, but its half-million figure is incredibly high when considering that the weekly Playboy magazine, which is targeted towards half the human population in Japan and not just gamers, prints 458,937 (certified figure).

[this message was edited by Professor on Fri 10 Mar 04:02]

Shooo-rook
107th Post

Regular Customer

"Re(8):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Fri 10 Mar 09:31

quote:

To put it another way, nobody that I know of reads Famitsu any more.

Still...500,000 people per week! Somebody is reading it. Mystery!

But doesn't GamePro -a magazine nobody would admit to owning- claim to have 3 million readers? I suspect Famitsu is counting the people who view illegally uploaded scans of their magazine as readers.

I don't like US game magazines all that much... One reason because some of them just plain suck... AND another reason (kind of OCD=ish)... the type of pages they use for their magazines are very poor quality, and I barf everytime my fingers touch those pages...

Also x box nation(XBN)- this magazine i bought like 3 issues of A long time ago had very good quality pictures and pages... but I remember they had a preview of Dead to Rights and it was their cover story... What a horrible game that turned out to be :(

Are you slave to the blade?

CHAZumaru

372th Post

Silver Customer

"FamitsuWave DVD and the Jaguar" , posted Sun 12 Mar 14:18

Speaking of Famichu~:

Courtesy of Nova, here's a feature from a recent FamitsuWave DVD about the AtariJaguar:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=HkkEuZFq0gc

NOW IS TIME TO THE 68000 Z80 AND SH-2 HEART ON FIRE !!

Burning Ranger

1381th Post

Red Carpet Executive Member

"Re(1):FamitsuWave DVD and the Jaguar" , posted Sun 12 Mar 15:32

quote:
Speaking of Famichu~:

Courtesy of Nova, here's a feature from a recent FamitsuWave DVD about the AtariJaguar:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=HkkEuZFq0gc

They didn't play Tempest 2000--which is the only redeeming game on the Jaguar.

Advanced Cyborg E. Branger AKA Burning Ranger

...and for Guilty Gear X2 # Reload!

Ammadeau

1498th Post

Red Carpet Executive Member

"Re(8):Top 100 game list from Famitsu?" , posted Sun 12 Mar 18:13

quote:
But doesn't GamePro -a magazine nobody would admit to owning- claim to have 3 million readers? I suspect Famitsu is counting the people who view illegally uploaded scans of their magazine as readers.

They also count the postman who delivers the magazine and the pets of the people who use the mags to line their cages as readers. How Gamepro still manages to exist, however, is still a mystery. Someone should make a CSI episode about it.

Ammadeau.net - My own personal waste of time.