Voice acting drama continues - http://www.mmcafe.com/ Forums

Return to site

Original message (1622 Views )

Ishmael

2066th Post

Platinum Carpet V.I.P- Board Master

"Voice acting drama continues" , posted Thu 23 Jun 04:26

Pulled from IMDB:

The Screen Actors Guild's national executive committee on Tuesday rejected a contract covering voice-over actors on video games, even though the deal had been unanimously approved by a SAG negotiating committee composed entirely of voice-over actors. SAG's sister union, the American Federation of Television and Radio Artists, has approved the contract. One member of SAG's board, who asked not to be identified, told today's (Wednesday) Los Angeles Times that the rejection represented a slap in the face to actors working in the video game industry. "We are now perceived in our own industry as an organization that does not bargain in good faith," the board member said. Daily Variety pointed out today that the vote now leaves union jurisdiction over the video game industry entirely to AFTRA with all pension and health contributions going to that union. The fact that the contract does not provide residual payments to voice-over actors appeared to be the divisive issue. The industry had maintained that the actors contribute little to the success of their games and that if they were to make residual payments to them, they would certainly have to do the same for all the other creative talent responsible for the games.

Replies:

Pollyanna

1204th Post

Red Carpet Executive Member

"Re(1):Voice acting drama continues" , posted Thu 23 Jun 07:09

Does anyone here think voice actors DESERVE residual payments?

exodus

2779th Post

Platinum Carpet V.I.P- Board Master

"Re(2):Voice acting drama continues" , posted Thu 23 Jun 07:14

quote:
Does anyone here think voice actors DESERVE residual payments?

*ahem*

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Not in games. In stuff like Futurama, yeah, because their voices are what makes it. But when you have a shrek game with blondie mcwhatshername just talking the way she talks, fuck that.

Gojira

1757th Post

Silver Carpet V.I.P- Platinum Executive

"Re(1):Voice acting drama continues" , posted Thu 23 Jun 07:30

Wow. Just wow. God, when I heard they were getting pay raises, it made me sick. That's worse than residuals, because it means they get more whether the game does well or not. And they turned it down at the last minute. What a bunch of morons. At this point they may as well get residuals with a minimum of 400,000 units moved. Meaning they don't get a damn penny unless the game sells more than that. It'll be worse than what they were already offered, but oh fucking well.

Radish

2927th Post

Platinum Carpet V.I.P- Board Master

"Re(3):Voice acting drama continues" , posted Thu 23 Jun 12:20

quote:
Does anyone here think voice actors DESERVE residual payments?

*ahem*

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Not in games. In stuff like Futurama, yeah, because their voices are what makes it. But when you have a shrek game with blondie mcwhatshername just talking the way she talks, fuck that.

Yeah I agree. Not to sound mean, but I think the VAs are overestimating their leverage. While it's great to have speach in games (as long as it's well acted) it certainly isn't soumething that's integral to the experiance. I mean, most Nintendo games recycle the same few "Mama Mia" and "HEY LISTEN!" lines and they seem to do fine.

Spoon

1109th Post

Red Carpet Premium Member+

"Re(4):Voice acting drama continues" , posted Thu 23 Jun 15:18

This is retarded.
And not in reference to the people posting, I mean.

Pollyanna

1212th Post

Red Carpet Executive Member

"Re(5):Voice acting drama continues" , posted Thu 23 Jun 17:00

Gojira: Actually, that's a good point. I would go for that. Even if it's a very high number, for BIG release games, that's reasonable. I don't think VAs deserve THAT much, but if the game is really racking in the money, then more people should benefit.

(On another note)

What about anime VAs, though? I mean, well...there's no such thing as an anime VA vs a game VA, but what I mean is, should they get money if the show they're in is broadcast?

As it is, the actors for a big show like DBZ get payed roughly the same rate a the actors for a DVD-only minor seller like Goemon.

exodus

2784th Post

Platinum Carpet V.I.P- Board Master

"Re(6):Voice acting drama continues" , posted Fri 24 Jun 01:12

quote:

What about anime VAs, though? I mean, well...there's no such thing as an anime VA vs a game VA, but what I mean is, should they get money if the show they're in is broadcast?

As much as they tend to suck, yeah, I think so.