Original message ([an error occurred while processing this directive] Views )[an error occurred while processing this directive]
| Just a Person 654th Post
 
Red Carpet Regular Member
  
    
    
|  "Question about Silent Hill (possible SPOILERS"
, posted Wed 4 Aug 11:39
Hi!
I have this question about the first Silent Hill game: you know you can make 4 endings (5, actually, but I'm not considering the UFO). The point is: I actually never had the courage to let Kauffman die or to kill Cybil. So, I wanted to know what happens if:
1) Kauffman dies in Annie's Bar. Sure, you are guided to the Bad/Bad+ endings, but do you actually hear him screaming before dying, do they show a scene of him dying, or is it just like he was never in the game?
2) you kill Cybil. This one is easier to answer, actually. If you throw the Aglaophotis in her, Harry and Cybil will talk for a while before she faints. When you decide to kill her, do they still have this same conversation before she dies?
That's it. Thanks, since now!!
I can be any person in the world ... maybe I'm this person right in front of you ... or maybe I'm not !!
|
|
Replies:
|
| Undead Fred 1828th Post
Silver Carpet V.I.P- Platinum Executive
  
    
 
| "Re(1):Question about Silent Hill (possible SP" , posted Wed 4 Aug 12:15
quote:
Hi!
I have this question about the first Silent Hill game: you know you can make 4 endings (5, actually, but I'm not considering the UFO). The point is: I actually never had the courage to let Kauffman die or to kill Cybil. So, I wanted to know what happens if:
1) Kauffman dies in Annie's Bar. Sure, you are guided to the Bad/Bad+ endings, but do you actually hear him screaming before dying, do they show a scene of him dying, or is it just like he was never in the game?
2) you kill Cybil. This one is easier to answer, actually. If you throw the Aglaophotis in her, Harry and Cybil will talk for a while before she faints. When you decide to kill her, do they still have this same conversation before she dies?
That's it. Thanks, since now!!
It's been so long since I've played the first one... I've always thought that Kaufmann had to live, but now that I think about it, I don't think he does. I've never seen what happens if he does die.
As for the Cybil thing, she just dies. I had played the game through several times without knowing what to do with the aglaophotis, so I've seen her die before. If you shoot her to death on the carousel, then she just dies and you go straight to the next part where Dahlia shows up to grab Alessa. You only get the little conversation about Cheryl if you save Cybil.
|
| JLG
1th Post
New Customer
| "Hella SPOILERS" , posted Wed 4 Aug 14:41:
If you go down the Bad/Bad+ ending path, you just never see Kaufmann ever again after that first meeting.
(I'm going to ruin the Bad/Bad+ endings (and Jacob's Ladder while I'm at it) now)
If Kaufmann and Cybil both die, Harry has to face Alessa/Cheryl as the final boss (as Kaufmann is too dead to throw the Aglaophotis at her). When he defeats her, she says, "Thank you, Daddy!" and then we see Harry slumped over dead in his car. The whole thing a death dream sorta like Jacob's Ladder.
If Kaufmann just dies, then Harry will still face Aleesa/Cheryl, only now at the end Cybil will come up and smack Harry upside the head and tells him to leave.
Speaking of Cybil, did Konami ever officially say if Cybil survived the whole ordeal? I'm hoping she did, but as far as I've heard, they've left it for the player to decide...
[this message was edited by JLG on Wed 4 Aug 14:42] |
| Just a Person 655th Post
Red Carpet Regular Member
| "Re(1):Question about Silent Hill (possible SP" , posted Wed 4 Aug 17:44
Thanks to everyone for the answers! I was hoping Cybil made her last speech before dying, but sadly it doesn´t happen...
About the fact if she survived SH1 or not, there are arguments about it. Some people say she can´t be alive, because if Harry used the Aglaophotis in her, then he couldn´t give it later to Heather; plus, Harry couldn´t know that the liquid could save Cybil, so it would be illogical to use it. Other people say she has to be alive, because Harry could have gotten more Aglaophotis in the town (Kauffman mentions there is more Aglaophotis from where he got his bottle), and that Douglas in SH3 mentions that Harry killed a man, but he never mentions Harry killing Cybil. I hope she´s alive, but maybe they´ll never answer this...
Other thing I´d like Konami to explain is about Myriam K. (mentioned in a grave in SH2). Walter had already some story in SH2 and SH4 adds more to his story, but they never mentioned who is Myriam K. and why is she a "Traitor"...
I can be any person in the world ... maybe I'm this person right in front of you ... or maybe I'm not !!
|
|
|
