Original message ([an error occurred while processing this directive] Views )[an error occurred while processing this directive]
| Adon 922th Post
 
Red Carpet Regular Member++
    
    
    
|  "Adon's top tens!! 2003 edition"
, posted Tue 8 Apr 19:56
All right after a little bit of thought and SNKvsCapcom on the horizon. I thought it would be cool to bring back the top ten character rankings. I figure that there are some new people here now and they could vote. Also, those who vote before can do so again. It would be interesting to compare the results from 2002 with the 2003 ones. I know that RB continued these for a bit. I'm sure he has the records of some characters that I did not include the 1st time around. This time I'm going to include the Rage of the Dragons characters the rest of the Art of Fighting, Fatal Fury, and KOF characters. This list of fighters is for 2D SNK and Capcom fighters only. The list includes any character that has had a role in the 2D genre, Playable and non playable. I’m not sure I will get every character but I should get most of them. I have in the neighborhood of 250 that need to be ranked. With that said I will explain how this works for new people. On a scale of 1 to 10 you rate character on their overall design. This includes any thing you want to consider story, design, culture, moves ect.. but it’s an over all rating reflecting this i.e. their overall popularity. I would break it down more but it too complex with such a large list of characters. So a score can be between the limits of 1.0 the worst score and 10.0 the best. If someone vote a 6.7 that is fine tenths are encouraged for a more accurate reflection. I think I will carry it out one more decimal place for better tie breakers this time example 7.12. Anything more then 10 like hundred, thousand, or million that will be interpreted as 10 any less then 1 like 0 or -85 that will be interpreted as a 1. The scores of everybody’s vote get averaged together for an overall score for that character. Last time I did 10 per thread this time I think I will do 25 per thread. So that will be around 10 different threads this being Adon's top ten 2003 edition part one. I will list the 2002 score with the character and if s character was not included last time I will list it as 1st vote. If you don't know about a certain character that is fine simply don’t vote. I can still average the results. RB if you have the results of a character I don’t have feel free to include their 2002 results. Well enough said time to vote! I will try to make them as random as possible.
Also feel free to leave a comment as to why you voted like "he is the coolest ever" or "that character sucks like that soda TAB in the pink can" ect..
1.Jubei(SS)
2002 average score 8.78
# of votes 5
2.Zangeif (SF)
2002 average 7.62
# of votes 9
3. Billy (ROTD)
1st vote
4.Rogue (Marvel)
2002 average 7.30
# of votes 10
5.Choi Bounge (KOF)
2002 average 5.44
# of votes 10
6.Karin(SFA3)
2002 average 8.26
# of votes 12
7.Necro (SF3)
2002 average 4.82
# of votes 11
8.Bonne Jenet (MOTW)
2002 average 8.69
# of votes 7
9.Terry Bogard
2002 average 8.50
# of votes 6
10.Chris(KOF)
2002 average 5.50
# of votes 11
11.Freeman (MOTW)
2002 average 5.27
# of votes 11
12.Benimaru (KOF)
2002 average 3.86
# of votes 7
13. Wolfgang Krauser (FF)
1st vote
14. Whip (KOF)
2002 average 7.08
# of votes 13
15. Rolento (SFA)
2002 average 6.90
# of votes 9
16. Haohmaru (SS)
2002 average 7.83
# of votes 9
17. Nakoruru (SS)
2002 average 8.09
# of votes 9
18. Cammy
2002 average 6.00
# of votes 9
19. Blanka
2002 average 6.51
# of votes 11
20. Mega Man (Marvel)
2002 average 7.38
# of votes 12
21. Mr. Jones (ROTD)
1st vote
22. Black Heart(Marvel)
2002 average 7.57
# of votes 11
23. Gambit(Marvel)
2002 average 8.43
# of votes 7
24. R. Mika(SFA3)
2002 average 4.72
# of votes 9
25. Joe Higashi (FF)
2002 average 7.38
# of votes 9
|
|
Replies:
|
| Time Mage 1354th Post
Red Carpet Executive Member
   
| "Re(2):Adon's top tens!! 2003 edition" , posted Wed 9 Apr 11:48
quote:
I'll vote a bit later, but did you check my vids?
Hagen: Number of votes is how many people bothered voting for them previously. Also, Adon, Mr. Jones and Billy aren't SNK...
Also, just a few other nit picks; It's easier to deal with the " 10 per thread " format, and you shouldn't exclude 3D fighters; neither company have that many 3D fighters, and many of the characters from these games either originally came from 2D fighters or could always end up in them (Kyosuke, etc.)
Um, yeah, I agree with Rugal, 10 per thread is easier to handle. Maybe 15, but 25 requires some time in front of the PC, time that I don't always have.
And the 3D chars should be included, or some cool ones like Shiki or Kyoko wouldn't be there...
Vanessa Z. Schneider!!
|
| Adon 926th Post
Red Carpet Regular Member++
| "Re(2):Adon's top tens!! 2003 edition" , posted Wed 9 Apr 13:31
quote:
I'll vote a bit later, but did you check my vids?
Hagen: Number of votes is how many people bothered voting for them previously. Also, Adon, Mr. Jones and Billy aren't SNK...
Also, just a few other nit picks; It's easier to deal with the " 10 per thread " format, and you shouldn't exclude 3D fighters; neither company have that many 3D fighters, and many of the characters from these games either originally came from 2D fighters or could always end up in them (Kyosuke, etc.)
Ahh ok should not be posting right now All ready late for work. Ok I won't put 25 per thread which will strech out the voting longer which is good. I will keep the 10 per thread method. Next the 3D fighters ok I will include them since they can make it into the 2D world. About the ROTD characters were they developed by Playmore? One last thing quickly before I rush out the door. RB, I was not able to see your vids. I went to the page and tried to open them and discovered I had an error with the temporary internet files. Basically I need to fix something with my comp to do that. I hope to that soon, Ok I will be back later
|
| Iron D 2161th Post
Platinum Carpet V.I.P- Board Master
    
| "Re(1):Adon's top tens!! 2003 edition" , posted Fri 11 Apr 14:43
Been a while since I've seen this. I think that not only should Evoga characters be excluded, but Marvel characters should too. My reasoning behind this is that I don't know whether to rate the Marvel characters as their "true" selves or as their Vs. game incarnations. Many characters like Cyclops and Rogue don't act ANYTHING like they do in the comics. I'd give Cyclops a 10 in the comics, but a 1 in the Vs. series. And on top of that, there is the obvious point that Capcom didn't create them, and thus they're not really Capcom characters.
On to the rankings:
1.Jubei(SS)8-Two swords. Eyepatch. Pimp.
2.Zangeif (SF)10-The Granddaddy of ALL grapplas. Bolischoy Tavieda!
3. Billy (ROTD)1-Ugh. I don't like what Evoga did to the original DD cast.
4.Rogue (Marvel) Comics-8. Vs. series-2
5.Choi Bounge (KOF)2-A crappy character who seems to only get crappier with time. Personality switch with Chang? What the crap?
6.Karin(SFA3)8-One of the few "schoolgirl" characters that I like.
7.Necro (SF3)8-A character I used to hate, but have grown to love. "Outta my way!"
8.Bonne Jenet (MOTW)3-That is supposed to be a pirate?
9.Terry Bogard 10-Dude, it's Terry Freakin' Bogard we're talkin' about here.
10.Chris(KOF)0-I'm forgetting if we can give 0's or not. If we can't then give this thing a .000000000000001 or something.
11.Freeman (MOTW)8-Oh yeah. Totally cool concept and desing for a character.
12.Benimaru (KOF)2-I'd give him lower, but at least he's got some cool supers. Oh, and "Do you undastand?"
13. Wolfgang Krauser (FF)7-Kick @$$ theme song (is that Mozart or Beethoven?), evil...oh yeah, but I still think that Geese would take him in a fight.
14. Whip (KOF)4-A character that I care less and less about as time goes by.
15. Rolento (SFA)9-Rolento's been cool ever since his Final Fight debut.
16. Haohmaru (SS)10-One of the coolest main characters ever.
17. Nakoruru (SS)5-meh.
18. Cammy 8-Cool moves and, with Delta Red, a cool design. I've loved her ever since her debut in SSF2.
19. Blanka 9-I can't give a specific reason for liking Blanka as much as I do, but I always have liked him alot.
20. Mega Man (Marvel)6-Marvel? What? Anyways, I'm diggin the whole "kiddy" thing, but I think he's cool otherwise.
21. Mr. Jones (ROTD)-10-Awful. Just awful.
22. Black Heart(Marvel)9-Kicks @$$, although he hasn't done anything in the comics for over a decade now.
23. Gambit(Marvel)10-One of the best comic book characters ever, and they have his personality down pretty well in the Vs. games.
24. R. Mika(SFA3)9-A female grappler with a gorgeous butt. Oh heck yeah!
25. Joe Higashi (FF)8-Another character that I once loathed but have grown to love.
Iron D-itude fact 1: Iron D got to see Wrestlemania XIX.
Iron D-itude fact 2: Iron D misses the MMCafe.
|
|
|
"The 1st round of voting on the 25 characters" 
"I wonder..." 
